Conversations about Gender Representation in Films and the Bechdel Test


I need to start this post with an apology to the third gender. This post shall focus on how women are under-represented in Hindi Films in India. The category of people that associate neither with the male or the female genders are also largely ignored by mainstream cinema even though they represent a decent section of the population. Unfortunately when stories have tracks for the third gender or the LGBTQ community in their stories, they are usually incorporated for comic relief.  Please go through the earlier hyperlinks to read about studies that analyse the under-representation of the third gender in our films.

Now there are every few households that don’t have any women in them. Our villages, towns and cities are filled with women. And yet our films don’t seem to reflect this too well.

Cinema in India enjoys a lot of love and has a very wide audience. This gives a lot of power to the filmmakers. But do they put their power to good use? Not really.

Last year, IBM and two New Delhi-based institutions released a public study of over 4,000 Hindi films to understand the extent of gender bias in the industry.

Here is a summary of the study findings (all graphs and images are snapshots from the report that you can read here):

1) Cast mentions in the Movie Plot: Right from 1970 to 2017, the data indicates that the male character has double the number of mentions as compared to a female character.

 Female mentions are present in Pink and Male mentions in Blue


 2) Cast Appearance in a Movie Plot: The adjectives most associated with males are: rich and wealthy while the verbs associated with them are kills and shoots. On the other hand, women characters are often described as beautiful and attractive while the verbs associated with them are marries and loves.

Adjectives for characters

3) Cast Introductions in a Movie Plot: Male characters are usually introduced by referencing their professions e.g. famous singer, an honest police officer, a successful scientist etc. while a woman character is invariably introduced in relation to a male character




 4) Occupation as a Stereotype: Women characters tend to have lower level occupations e.g. teacher or student while the male character tends to have higher level occupations such as lawyer or doctor.


Occupations for men


Occupations for Women

5) Cast Dialogues and Gender Gap in Movie Scripts: On studying the ratio of male to female dialogues in 13 scripts, it was found that Raman Raghav was the least biased while Kaminey and Aligarh showed the most bias.


Female dialogues are presented on X-axis and Male dialogues on Y-axis

6) Movie Poster and Plot mentions: Publicizing a movie is biased towards a female on advertising material like posters, and they end up having an even smaller or inconsequential role in the movie. 50% of movie posters had female representation but 80% of the movies had more male mentions than female. Notably, 3 movies - GangaaJal 2 , Platform 3 , Raees 4 had almost 100+ male mentions in the plot but no female mentions whereas in all 3 posters females were prominently present on posters.

                 Source- Pixabay

7) Movie Trailers: The screen time for women characters in movie trailers has consistently been half that of men for over a decade!


8)  Female Centricity: The good news is that the female centric movies and female mentions in our movies are on a rise.

  


9) Singers and gender distribution in soundtracks: Since the female actors have a lesser role to play, so do their voices. Right from 2010 to 2017, the female singers have sung consistently less songs as compared to their male counterparts. The duration of the song sung by the female singer has not been considered here but it is more likely to be lopsided. This fact was also corroborated in a recent interview with the top female singers in the country.

Sexism not covered by the study above

Other than the garden variety of sexism that persists worldwide,women are further objectified through ‘Item Numbers’ in our Hindi Films. The term itself is offensive. Kangana Ranaut depicts the widely prevalent sexism in a viral video in collaboration with AIB, a popular Indian comedy sketch group. You can read the on-point lyrics of this parody item number– ‘The Bollywood Diva Song’ here.

And of course we know this – the top male ‘superstars’ of our country are all 50 years old and prefer to pair with actresses half their age! Most of our 300 crore films fail the ‘Jane Test’ for this reason (read about the Test later in the post)! Fortunately the trend of female actors who vanish from the screen on getting married is changing today.

The report concludes by suggesting that the primary steps one can take to narrow the gap of gender bias in Hindi Films is by:

a)  Removing Occupation Hierarchy –Moving away from stereotypical occupations
b)  Removing Gender Bias from plots – Ask important questions like, ‘If one interchanges 
all  males and females, is the plot/story still possible or plausible?’

This brings us to the second part of my post…

THE RELEVANCE OF THE BECHDEL TEST

First let us understand…

What is the Bechdel test?

The Bechdel Test is a measure of gender inequality, particularly in films but it is also being used as a tool for Feminism in plays and short stories as well.

It was created by American cartoonist, Alison Bechdel in her 1985 comic, “Dykes to Watch Out For”. It is also known as the Bechdel-Wallace test.

To pass the test, the story has to have at least two unnamed or named female characters who talk to each other about something other than a man.

Women’s Web, a forum for women requires contributors to submit short stories that pass the Bechdel Test for its Monthly Muse contest. The measure is used widely across the globe. 

But is the Bechdel Test the ideal measure of gender bias in stories? I don’t think so.

Many people across the world including the creator of the test, Alison Bechdel acknowledge that the test isn’t perfect and may not always work. It definitely highlights the problem but its simplicity can be its undoing. Let us break the test down to highlight its failings:

                 a)            Two women must speak to one another

In a recently released short film produced by Anurag Kashyap and Shlok Sharma, the viewer takes the same emotional journey as the characters in the film take after a very traumatic event. There were no dialogues and yet the film makes you empathize with a woman’s anguish.

               b)            The two women must talk to each other about something other than a man.

There are various scenarios where two women could talk about a man and yet have a feminist flavour.  One important scenario could be conversations about abuse. A woman pushing her friend/ colleague/ daughter to stand up for her rights cannot take place without mentioning the man! Such empowering conversations will fail the Bechdel test!         

The film Gravity does not pass the Bechdel Test even though it revolves around a woman astronaut who survives in space owing to her intelligence and grit.  Read here on how even though most of the highest grossing films in Hollywood passed the Bechdel Test, the issue of gender bias remains largely unsolved.

If not the Bechdel Test, then what?

The Bechdel Test may still be the most popular measure but there are other tests that could be used to supplement it to get a clearer picture of gender biasedness in films.

1)  The JaneTest:

Script-reader Ross Putman highlighted the sexism that prevails in Hollywood by sharing the character descriptions for the female lead from actual scripts in a feed on Twitter using the handle @femscriptintros. It was found that most of the descriptions only focussed on how the character looked. He replaced all the names with ‘Jane’ which is why it is called the Jane Test. According to Ross 3 questions must be asked by writers before crafting the female lead:

                a.            Does the introduction focus on the external attributes of the character?
                b.            Is he a twenty- or thirty something?
                c.            Is she dating someone decades older than her?

If your answer is ‘Yes’ to all the questions above, then the script fails the Jane Test.

2)  Samantha Ellis, a feminist playwright in Hollywood, devised the Sphinx Test’ that also involved asking a series of questions for playwrights to consider while creating a female character:

                a            Is there a woman centre stage?
                b.           Is she active rather than reactive?
                c.           Is she compelling and complex?

3)  Read here to know 12 tests that checks gender bias across 4 main aspects of movie-making:

               a.            Behind the Camera
               b.            Intersectional
               c.            Protagonists
               d.            Supporting Cast

These tests emerged when FiveThirtyEight (a website that focuses on opinion poll analysis, politics, economics, and sports blogging) asked 13 people in the entertainment industry to come up with personal standards for representation in cinema.

Gender Inequality behind the scenes

The study on Hindi Films doesn’t touch upon the lack of women film makers (directors, producers, editors, camerawomen etc.) in the industry. According to this article in 2016, there were only around 60 women working behind the scenes in big ticket movies. Here is a quote from a cinematographer who happens to be a woman explaining the reason–

”The opportunities are fewer because you are judged already right at the beginning on the basis of gender. I don’t understand what a ‘physical film’ means. I don’t understand why a man can shoot this and I can’t.”

This was in response to a comment by a reviewer who was surprised that the cinematographer was a woman. Also do read Shit People Say To Women Directors and other Women in Film.

No money for Feminism

When a movie like ‘Masaan’ is made, portraying a strong and independent girl from the small-town of Benares, I am sure it inspires women everywhere. Of course we know the love that ‘Queen’ or even the ‘Tanu weds Manu’ films have received from the audience. But I don’t think the makers set out to make ‘feminist’ films. They wrote stories that they themselves believed in. Richa Chaddha praises the makers of Masaan in a recent interview: ‘Neeraj Ghaywan and Varun Grover are possibly the most progressive (and) intelligent men I know who are so non-judgemental, understanding and humane…’ Neeraj Ghaywan followed Masaan with an amazing short film ‘Juice’ starring Shefali Shah that focussed on the sexism and patriarchy that still pervades our Indian homes. There are several other short films that aim to highlight the sexism that exists in India.

You may argue that the above films and short films are all made on relatively low budgets. Without the financial risks that a big-budget movie faces, these inspirational stories can afford to lend themselves to feminist ideals. True. But there is a glimmer of hope. I think that the reason why you saw the improving trends in female centric movies recently in the study earlier is because data suggests that half of the movie-goers are women today! This was not the case in the 80’s or 90’s where the movies catered primarily to men. As the women audience members watch more women centric films they will drive the demand upwards for such films. The consistent success of these films will make film-makers less wary of creating such films.

At the end of the day, no matter how many tests, questions and studies we subject our movies to, the fact is that writers want to share stories about the world around them. And unfortunately as long as sexism prevails in India, you can’t blame cinema or stories for mirroring the reality. Let’s try and make our women feel more as equals. Then our stories will also reflect it.




Comments

  1. You have put in lot of research into this post. Well done.Though we all knew this, seeing it in print gives a hollow feeling in the heart

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is such an informative and in-depth post. All this research must have taken a lot of effort. I agree with Meena, seeing it in print leaves one with a hollow feeling in the heart. This post should be required reading for all students of cinema! Thank you so much for making all the effort to get this information out there.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Meena and Neha...a big thank you for your kind comments and coming back to visit blog. :) My posts begin with a thought and then I look out for research that supports it.

    Just like you, I had a hunch about the gender inequality present in our fims. Then I came across a few articles and this study. I am glad it was done. It is gut-wrenching.

    About the Bechdel Test...with my limited exposure to it also, I realized it has flaws and looked for alternate answers.

    Thanks again for reading through the whole post. Sometimes my posts get a little too long. But I feel that it will still reach the audience it is meant to reach.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Wow! This is such a well researched piece. Knew about Bechdel test as I am associated with Womensweb and have submitted stories for the muse of the month contest. Rest everything was a revelation. Great post!!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks Meha. :) Looking forward to reading more of your writing on the Women's Web and elsewhere! :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well researched really.keep up the good work.
    Here from Second thoughts First

    ReplyDelete
  7. well researched and extensive post. Just learnt about the Bechdel test.
    You could drop by https://sukrisblog.wordpress.com/2018/04/03/childlike-or-childish

    ReplyDelete
  8. What a well researched post. I didn't about the Bechdel test, thanks to you, now I do. Please keep on posting such informative articles, it's good for us.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This was very interesting. It is apparent you have done tons of research before penning down your views. Brilliant insights.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi Sudha and Anusha...thank you for having visited by blog and read this rather long post. Thank you for your rather nice comments. Glad you're taking something away from it. :)

    Hi Lavanya. Thank you for reading my post and your appreciation. Hope you shall come back to read my upcoming posts as well :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. There seems to be a lot of research into this post Ashwini. Can I take a look at the sources for these graphs?

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi Arjun. The links for all the source material are provided in the post itself. If you are referring to the source for the gender discrimination in films I am sharing the link for the public study here as well https://arxiv.org/pdf/1710.04117.pdf

    ReplyDelete
  13. kudos for the research. I loved this post!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thanks Deepa for your encouragment. :)

    ReplyDelete
  15. That was truly an indepth post Ashwini. You have unearthed and presented the research and tests really well. Would love reading more of your work.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thank you Namratha for the patience to read this rather long post. The internet makes it so easy for me to back my ideas. :) But yes, this topic was quite close to my heart. Do visit my blog again. :)

    ReplyDelete
  17. Anonymous7:59 pm

    Wow Ashwini! Kudos for this. I can't imagine the amount of reasearch you must have done for this. Hats off. ( I can't post on blogspot for the life of me.so posting anyonymous. Priya from priyreflects)

    ReplyDelete
  18. Thanks Priya. Appreciate your effort in posting. And thanks a lot for appreciating my efforts in creating this blog post. :)

    ReplyDelete
  19. Wow! I see the kind of research and painstaking effort that has gone into this post. Really commendable.

    The Indian movie industry (and sadly, even viewers) have a very perverted and outdated view of women's roles in movies and in life in general. Although we are now in the 21st century, we still like to see our heroines limit themselves to the kitchen and the bedroom, while the hero goes out saving the world and Saturn's farthest satellite. Things are changing, but I think the degree of change will continue to remain slow until our society starts evolving.

    Lovely post. All the best for the rest of the A to Z Challenge.

    Cheers,
    CRD
    SCRIPTED IN SANITY

    ReplyDelete
  20. Thanks CRD for your kind words. I believe things are and will change. All of us just need to have the ability to call a spade a spade. Then looking for solutions will be easier. Today we are not even acknowledging that there is a problem. This study was so important to have been carried out. It lays it out there...in black and white.

    Best of luck to you too for the A to Z challenge. Hope to see you soon. :)

    ReplyDelete
  21. Films definitely influence our thought process so it's great that more realistic films that give women a voice are bieng made now. Love your well researched posts!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Nupur for your visit, read and thoughtful comment. As more women filmmakers joint the industry behind the camera, we will see more realistic movies on screen I think.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Don’t let Gaslighting and other forms of emotional abuse make you forget your true self

Rape Culture Is Real

What Women Don't Want